As we watch the stream of sadhus file past our
encampment on their way along the Ganges to the Maha Kumbha Mela, we cant help
noticing that almost all the orange robed ascetics are men. What is a womans role in
the mela? Are women assigned leadership positions in the Indian spiritual tradition? Actually
as we stroll through the mela itself we quickly note that a substantial minority of the
makeshift ashrams that have sprouted over the Allahabad floodplain are devoted to women
spiritual masters. Not only male voices but female tones resound from the numberless
loudspeakers blaring 24 hours a day with religious instruction or devotional singing.
Still, female renunciates are rare in this part of the country. You are more likely to
encounter women sadhus, called bhairavis, in Bengal and Assam in the far northeast of
India where the fierce forms of the Goddess are particularly venerated and independent
women are more readily accepted.
We know from the Vedic literature that in ancient times the spiritual status of women
here was quite high. Women like Ambhrini, Lopamudra, Anasuya, and Maitreyi were
represented as adepts or scholars. Lopamudra, a princess from the area around Benares,
became the spiritual preceptor of her husband, the great Vedic teacher Agastya. That
exceptional scholarship among women in India continued into medieval times is evident from
a well known story about Shankaracharya, the best known exponent of Vedantic philosophy.
The only time he was almost defeated in debate was by Bharati Mishra, a leading women
practitioner of Mimansa, ritualistic spiritual practice.
Many women in Indian culture prefer to do their practices in the privacy of their own
homes. Their saintly nature may be recognized in their local area but women saints known
throughout the subcontinent were few till the 20th century.
The last century saw the breakthrough of many women to leadership positions. Sarada
Devi, wife of Ramakrishna Paramahansa, is considered the mother of Bengal, and its
unusual to find a Bengali home where her picture isnt displayed. Anandamayi Ma, born
in the portion of Greater India now called Bangladesh, counted some of Indias top
scholars, including Gopinath Kaviraj, among her followers. Numerous books are available in
English detailing her amazing life and teachings.
Amritanandamayi Ma may be the best known woman saint in India today-her ashram has a
booth here at the mela. Born in abject poverty in Kerala in southwestern India, Ammachi
(beloved mother as her devotees call her) today heads a massive charitable
effort that includes building hospitals, hospices, vocational training institutes,
orphanages, and temples throughout India. She has recently committed to constructing 5000
new homes each year which are offered free of charge to destitute women and their
families.
Western feminists, basing their theories on distorted notions of Indian history
concocted by 19th century Orientalists, helped perpetuate the myth that India was once
largely Dravidian and matriarchal, and that the Vedic Aryans invaded the northern
subcontinent around 1500 BC, driving the native population south, and initiating strict
patriarchy. Scholars with more respect for the Indians own version of their history,
as well as with better knowledge of the archeological evidence which has emerged over the
past few decades, now realize this picture is false.
It now appears that the Aryans have been in northern India from time immemorial and
that the Dravidians were always based in the south, as their own traditions affirm.
However, sometime between 1000 BC and 500 AD waves of invaders from Mongolia, Indochina
and Turkey entered the country, introducing their pastoral culture which overvalued male
roles and undercut womens rights. The sad consequences of these incursions are still
evident in womens diminished status in India today.
Over the centuries some tantric teachers undertook to restore a balance in male/female
relationships, at least spiritually. Some tantric groups waived requirements for
initiation such as high caste and male gender in favor of adhikara,
worthiness. By this fairer standard anyone who proved spiritually worthy,
regardless of caste or gender, could be initiated into the groups practices.
The bhakta movement of fervent devotion for God that swept India in medieval times also
helped bring to prominence numbers of great spiritual women. Many great bhaktas were
female, of whom the most famous example is Mira Bai, the passionate devotee of Krishna
from northwestern India.
More recently the yoga masters themselves have been at work redressing the sexual
disparities in Indian culture today. Many highly noted male gurus have passed the
leadership of their lineages to female disciples. These gurus include Sri Aurobindo,
Ramakrishna Paramahansa, Ram Das, Muktananda, and the famous humanitarian Madhusudhan Das.
Some Buddhists and Jains deny that women are capable of enlightenment. But the earliest
and most authoritative Indian scripture, the Veda, was composed by both male and female
seers, called brahma rishis and brahma vadinis respectively. To deny the full spiritual
potential of women would be the equivalent of denying the Veda, or at least those portions
of it originally cognized by extraordinary women mystics such as Ambhrini.
It is perhaps no coincidence that the Veda is viewed as the embodiment of a goddess
(Vach, more commonly known as Sarasvati) and that its most sacred prayer, the gayatri
mantra, is symbolized by the goddess Gayatri. In a culture where divine attributes are
often represented as feminine, the near total suppression of womens roles as
spiritual leaders which occurred in the West (where women are still largely denied roles
as priests, pastors or popes), could not ultimately succeed.